Did You Meet Your Objectives This 12 months? – Pff, We Don’t Care

Picture by rawpixel.com on Freepik

article high

Our Legislature’s 2023 session is unquestionably cranked up now.  Committees are revving up and sending out gobs of notices of listening to for the payments earlier than them.  The Legislature is coping with over 3,000 payments launched this yr, positively much more than common and could also be a report quantity.

One of many different duties that legislators have is oversight of our Govt Department businesses.  This can be a regular operate of presidency.  We elect legislators.  Legislators management the purse strings, and they should guarantee that the tax cash we entrust to them is being spent correctly and effectively.


To facilitate this oversight operate, we have now various legal guidelines that bear on the budgeting course of.  Considered one of them, HRS part 37-75, requires businesses to return up a “variance report” that’s alleged to checklist how a lot they had been budgeted, how a lot was spent, and a story clarification for any vital distinction.  Businesses are additionally tasked with deciding on some metrics that may assist the legislators and the general public see how they did, and with posting these metrics.  These studies are due 30 days earlier than the beginning of the legislative session.  They’re collected by the Division of Funds and Finance, and are posted right here. 

4 years in the past, we examined a number of the variance studies and concluded that some, not all, of the businesses had been mainly thumbing their noses on the course of.  We had been hopeful that by bringing these details to mild we might maybe disgrace a few of these businesses to get again on the straight and slender path.

Apparently, that didn’t work.

Beneath the Transportation class, right here is a part of the variance report for the Daniel Ok. Inouye Worldwide Airport:

“Variety of accidents per 100,000 sq. ft – NO DATA.”  They clearly understand how massive their space is in sq. ft, so are they telling us they don’t maintain monitor of accidents?  That’s onerous to consider.  “Common variety of instances airport restrooms are cleaned per day – NO DATA.”  Are you kidding me?  This, by the way in which, is just not an issue distinctive to Honolulu.  Information for Hilo Worldwide Airport, Ellison Onizuka Kona Worldwide Airport at Keahole, Kahului Airport, Lihue Airport, and ALL of the opposite airports report the same lack of knowledge for the metrics, simply as they did 4 years in the past.

These, chances are you’ll keep in mind, are metrics they picked themselves.  As we reported 4 years in the past, Airports’ variance studies in prior years did certainly measure these statistics, as much as the 2014-15 variance report.  In that yr’s report, the Airports Division complained that “lots of its measures are not related and outdated,” and stopped following the regulation at the moment.

In 2019, we additionally complained concerning the jail system, which had been reporting “NO DATA” when measuring what number of escapes, each first and second diploma, had occurred.  Thankfully, they appear to have gotten the message and have been posting knowledge because the fiscal yr 2020 report.  No escapes!

On the identical time, new cases of businesses posting “NO DATA” in response to key metrics are popping up.  The Workplace of Environmental High quality Management, for instance, posted “NO DATA” in response to all metrics in its 2022 variance report, saying it couldn’t compile knowledge as a result of it was transferred to be below one other company this previous yr.  The College of Hawaii Most cancers Heart is itemizing no knowledge, saying that it’s a new program established by the Legislature.  Actually?  The Most cancers Heart has been round since 1971, so there’s one thing I’m not understanding right here.

For our authorities to function effectively and to be pretty evaluated, we want good knowledge and transparency.  Let’s maintain urgent for good knowledge.